Should I invest in ETFs?

For many investors, an ETF is a more efficient wrapper than a comparable mutual fund. It often costs less and distributes fewer taxable gains. But an ETF is a container, not a strategy, so what it holds and whether it fits your goals, taxes and timeline matters more than the label. Sometimes the right choice is an ETF, and sometimes it is a mutual fund or something else entirely.

ETFs Are Making Headlines - Here’s What Really Matters

If you've followed financial news recently, you've probably noticed a great deal of attention surrounding exchange-traded funds (ETFs). New ETFs seem to launch almost daily, and many well-known investment firms have announced plans to convert long-standing mutual funds into ETFs.

For many investors, this raises a natural question: Should I be investing in ETFs instead of mutual funds?

For our clients, the answer may seem familiar because, in many cases, you already are.

Long before ETFs became one of the investment industry's fastest-growing segments, we made them a cornerstone of many client portfolios. In fact, many of our clients own portfolios comprised entirely of ETFs, while others hold only a small number of mutual funds where we believe they remain the best available solution.

This isn't because we've followed the latest industry trend. Rather, we've long believed that, for many investment strategies, the ETF structure offers meaningful advantages. More importantly, we've always believed that selecting the right investment vehicle is just one part of building a successful portfolio.

An ETF Is Not an Investment Strategy

One of the biggest misconceptions surrounding ETFs is that they represent a particular investment philosophy. They don't. An ETF is simply an investment structure—a vehicle that holds stocks, bonds, or other investments. Think of it as the wrapper around the investment itself. An ETF can track a broad market index, be actively managed, focus on a specific industry, invest in bonds, generate income, or pursue countless other strategies. The investment wrapper matters, but what is inside the wrapper matters even more.

Why We've Long Favored ETFs

For many investment strategies, ETFs offer several advantages over traditional mutual funds.

Greater tax efficiency. Because of the way ETF shares are created and redeemed, they often distribute fewer taxable capital gains than comparable mutual funds. For investors holding assets in taxable accounts, this can improve after-tax returns over time.

Lower costs. The growth of the ETF marketplace has created intense competition, resulting in many high-quality investment options with very low operating expenses.

Trading flexibility. Unlike mutual funds, which are priced once each day after the market closes, ETFs trade throughout the trading day. While long-term investors rarely need intraday trading, the added flexibility can be beneficial when implementing portfolio changes.

Transparency. Most ETFs disclose their holdings daily, allowing investors and advisors to know exactly what they own.

These advantages explain why so many investment firms are now converting mutual funds into ETF structures. In many cases, the underlying investment strategy hasn't changed at all. The portfolio manager, investment philosophy, and holdings remain largely the same. The investment is simply being delivered through a more efficient vehicle.

Implementation Matters

Although ETFs offer many advantages, they also require thoughtful implementation.

Unlike mutual funds, ETFs trade on an exchange just like individual stocks. Every ETF has a bid price (what buyers are willing to pay) and an ask price (what sellers are asking). The difference between the two—the bid-ask spread—may represent a premium or a discount to the value of the underlying portfolio.

For broad, heavily traded ETFs, the spread is often only a penny per share or less and has little impact. However, for more specialized or less frequently traded ETFs, the spread can be considerably wider.

This is one reason why successful investing involves more than simply selecting the right investments. It also requires careful execution. When buying or selling ETFs, we routinely use trading techniques such as limit orders and pay close attention to market liquidity in an effort to obtain efficient execution and avoid paying more—or accepting less—than necessary.

These details may seem small, but over time they can contribute to better investment outcomes.

The Best Investment Isn't Always an ETF

While we've long favored ETFs, we don't believe they're automatically the best choice in every situation.

Some exceptional investment strategies simply aren't available in ETF form. Certain actively managed mutual funds continue to offer capabilities that have yet to be replicated in an ETF. Likewise, some specialized investment opportunities require entirely different structures.

Today's investment landscape offers far more than just mutual funds and ETFs. Depending on a client's objectives, a portfolio may also include managed portfolios of individual stocks and bonds, direct indexing strategies, interval funds, private equity, private credit, private real estate, or other alternative investments.

Each of these investment structures has its own advantages, limitations, tax characteristics, liquidity considerations, and role within a diversified portfolio.

Our responsibility isn't to champion one investment vehicle over another. It's to understand the strengths and weaknesses of each and determine when—and if—it belongs in a client's financial plan.

Looking Beyond the Investment Wrapper

The continued growth of ETFs reflects healthy innovation within the investment industry, and we welcome that progress. More efficient investment vehicles ultimately benefit investors.

At the same time, we believe investors should avoid confusing the investment wrapper with the investment itself.

An ETF can hold an exceptional portfolio—or a poor one. The same is true of a mutual fund, a separately managed account, a direct indexing strategy, or an alternative investment. The structure alone doesn't determine investment success.

Our investment process begins by understanding each client's goals, risk tolerance, tax situation, income needs, and long-term objectives. From there, we evaluate the broad universe of available investment solutions and select the combination we believe is best suited to help achieve those goals.

Sometimes that's an ETF. Sometimes it's a mutual fund. Sometimes it's a managed portfolio of individual securities, a direct indexing strategy, or a private market investment.

What matters isn't the label on the investment. What matters is whether it's the right solution for the client.

As investment products continue to evolve, our philosophy remains unchanged. We will continue evaluating the full spectrum of investment opportunities, embracing new innovations when they provide meaningful benefits, and implementing those investments with care and discipline. Our goal has never been to build portfolios around the latest industry trend. Our goal is to build portfolios around our clients—using the investment structures and strategies we believe offer the greatest opportunity to help them achieve their long-term financial goals.

This article is for educational purposes only. It does not represent investment advice. It is not a solicitation for advisory services nor is it intended to be used as investment, tax, legal, accounting, insurance, or financial planning advice. References and/or links to third parties do not constitute an endorsement. We have no relationship with any third party referenced in this article. Consult with us or another qualified professional before acting on any of the information presented herein.

Let's talk about what matters to you.

A complimentary 30-minute conversation. No obligation.

Schedule a conversation

Prefer to start with an email? Write to us at info@F2Wealth.com.

What to expect

  • We listen first: your goals, your questions, what's on your mind.
  • We explain how we work, including how we're paid.
  • You leave with clearer next steps, whether or not we work together.